I see a lot of posts going around talking about the need to be critical of fanfic, and how we gotta watch out for the messages we’re sending
Well, here’s one thing I’m gonna need us to be critical about:
Every statistic I’ve ever seen says fanfic authors are heavily female (or nb)
And Tumblr, which is a fairly US-centric cross-section of fandom, is filled with this discourse about fanfic writers who create pornography
I need us to stop and think about why we’ve decided that fictional sex is the most damaging thing anyone could ever find on the internet
I need us to think about the culture we live in, which encourages us to be sexually available (to straight men) but punishes us if we (sluts) enjoy it
Because here’s the thing: fanfic is not coming from a position of power and prestige in our society
It is a niche genre primarily written by women, for women, for free
And it is a place where many of us do find power in exploring our own sexuality (or asexuality)
Even when that exploration takes us to gritty, horrifying (or cathartic) places
I’m going to need us to think long and hard about why we’re prioritizing fictional characters over the needs of real women
And I’m going to need it to stop
Fandom purity wank is absolutely about control over women and women’s sexuality. There’s nothing ambiguous about it.
Just think about the hot-button issues in the fannish community, the topics that consistently and reliably get people worked up into a lather, the themes that provoke the nastiest conflicts and inspire the most dedicated resistance movements. Think about the fights that are most likely to spill out over their cyber boundaries and start affecting people in the real world - in public harassment at cons, in doxxing and ‘outing’ to family and employers, in malicious legal allegations.
It’s about sex. It’s always about sex.
From the constant tantrums over ‘problematic’ shipping to the righteous doxxing of ‘pedophiles’ (which in current tumblr parlance means anyone who draws or writes canonically underage characters in romantic or erotic scenarios), fandom’s big efforts at moral reform always seem to revolve around restricting and controlling the sexual expression of the majority-women community. You won’t meet many people who stay up past their bedtime to scream at strangers on the internet about unethical portrayals of non-sexual violence - unless, of course, they suspect the women involved in its creation are getting off on it. You’ll struggle to find an anti blog dedicated to the insidious social ills of torture whump fic, or goopy hurt-comfort where all manner of human suffering is put on display for the viewer’s enjoyment. The purity crew dress up their agenda as a desire for collective self-improvement and raised moral standards, but they don’t seem too worried about aspects of public morality that don’t somehow tie back into sex. What they’re upset about is the same thing conservative minds have been upset about since basically the dawn of time - there are women out there in the world doing icky sex things without the permission of their communities.
And these people, these moral guardians, they’ve gotten really good at couching their fundamentalist views in progressive language. They don’t say ‘you’re to blame if you provoke men to rape’ - they say ‘your fic normalises sexual violence and contributes to rape culture’. They don’t say ‘women ought to be chaste’ - they say ‘your fantasies are socially harmful and you owe it to the world to be more self-critical’. The messages are the same and the desired outcomes are literally identical.
The core assumption underlying all of it - an assumption that I’m sure our puritan forebears would find deeply comforting - is that women’s sexual expression is a matter of public concern, and that women are directly responsible for upholding the moral standards of their communities by restricting themselves to a narrow repertoire of publicly controlled, socially condoned sexual outlets. Anything beyond that repertoire is a grave moral breach.
To anyone who’s reading this - and there’s always a few - thinking, “this is just deflection! [X hot-button topic] is really bad and harmful!’, I’d like to encourage you to sit back for just a moment and think about why it is, exactly, that you feel the best and most important place to wage your war against moral corruption is in one of the only pockets of popular media that women unequivocally control. Of all the spaces in the world where you could be fighting for your view of a better society, you’ve chosen a place where women come together to share the fantasies that mainstream culture refuses to let them indulge. Why?
“…women come together to share the fantasies that mainstream culture refuses to let them indulge.”
I was just telling a friend of mine I attribute my (fortunate) comfort with my own sexuality to a chance encounter, at a very young age, with a paperback titled “My Secret Garden: Women’s Sexual Fantasies,” by Nancy Friday. Found it in a stack of mystery novels, and man, I remember blushing so hard… It was reading all these fantasies other women had that normalized what, at that young age, I considered to be pretty extreme desires, all in the context of this authority saying, “Anything you fantasize in the privacy of your own head is perfectly natural and okay.” She asked hundreds of women to share these fantasies so that others could read them and see we aren’t alone; most everyone has these thoughts and fantasies and desires, and that’s perfectly fine. Since then, I’ve discovered fan fiction as a whole universe of people’s fantasies writ large, and goddamn it, that is perfectly fine. Anyone who wants to argue the point and try to stuff us all back into the cramped cupboard of shame should have a talk with Ms. Friday. I believe she’s still around.
Agreed. Women are shamed for exploring dark themes everywhere else. Fandom does not need to be a safe haven for people who never want to hear about that: the entire rest of the world is a safe haven for anti-kink, anti-sex, anti-woman feelings.
Ship and let ship, don’t like don’t read, and your kink is not my kink and that’s okay: these are the maxims that make fandom a welcoming, creative space.
“Fandom does not need to be a safe haven for people who never want to hear about that: the entire rest of the world is a safe haven for anti-kink, anti-sex, anti-woman feelings.”
There are a lot of corners of fandom that need this (metaphorically) branded on their foreheads.
*raises hand*
I’m one of those people who have said such things as ‘this normalises this and that" (mainly rape culture, homophobia, pedophilia, racism, and some biological nonsense) and I stand by that.
Representation matters.
For me there is a definite line between “exploring dark themes” and normalising the same. And that line is basically some awareness that what the fictional characters are doing is wrong and that real life requires consent and respect.
It’s as easy as that, but I’ve seen fan content where that awareness is totally missing and those are the times I’m really bothered.
I’m also *not* agreeing that mainstream culture are against such things as rape fantasies and pedophilia, leaving fandom to be the one free space for such things.
I could talk for several paragraphs about how both those things are present in films like Suicide Squad, how ‘teen’ is a porn genre, and so on.
For some kinks this is true sure, but not the ones that I have major issues with. Fanworks are just a reflection of society at large when it comes to things like that.
But that’s not really what I want to talk about now, because while one of the peeps above say that fandom can’t be a safe space can we please please please mention tagging?
If you want to have rape, pedophilia, homophobia, racism, and all other things I would rather not see in fanfic then you are right, I can just not read those fanfics. No harm no foul.
But only if you make it clear that’s what they are.
There’s always something we don’t want to read, regardless of what kinks we have.
Just because you’re into rape fantasies you might be a bit ?!! if the characters start shitting on each other in the middle of it or was suddenly wearing diapers, or in animal costumes. Because other people’s kinks isn’t necessarily for you.
So use tags when appropriate, thank you.
Oooooh I’ve been wondering about this lately. Yes representation matters! People can and do internalize unhealthy messages from fiction - it’s almost like fiction is a tool for teaching culture or something.
On one hand there is the perception that women are feeble minded and less able to access the ManLogic needed to tell the difference between fantasy and reality. Maybe it’s true, if vampires ever take over the world I’ll just offer myself up as a snack/BDSM sub instead of standing and fighting because too much fanfic.*
Do any other Olds remember when no one seemed to get weirded out by depictions of drunk sex? I’m not saying it was an all across the board thing, but I will say think there’s been a change. It’s a change I’m very glad to see in the fandom world.
* jk I’m mostly a top.😜
This was a wee bit rambly…but I mean to vocalize some conflicting thoughts/feelings on theater.
Please don’t mind me. I am a feeble minded little lady who clearly needs someone to tell me when I am a ‘sinnin…..
Back in the 1990s, when we held a panel at Escapade* about “Women Who Are Ready To Admit They Like Rape Fic” they solemnly shut the door to the panel room and said: “The first step is to admit that it is OK to be a woman and to like to read or write rape fic.” The second step: no shaming…”
Up until then, we had been told that we were badwrongdirtysickfuckedupaskingforit.
It seems we still are being told….Or rather, it seems they are still trying to tell us. But I am still not buying what they are peddling. This is not an either/or world with the morally pure knights on one side and the dirtybadwrong sinners on the other side. There should be room for evaluating the impact of culture/fiction/theatre/movies in our lives. Many of us raged against the Twilight books and have written about why that genre of fiction is harmful to young women, but you don’t change social norms by shaming those who are reading and writing and consuming.
*A slash convention held in California every Feb/March